A Perfect Circle
Okay, now that I have listened to everything in extent, I will review all that is APC that I know of, minus aMotion, I do not have that DVD yet.
Mer de Noms - This album is their first effort, and my my my, what an effort it is. The disc starts with The Hollow, which in and of itself speaks of a desire to seek what can fill a hollow "heart". Straight to the end with Over. It's a perfect mix of radio-friendly tunes that is sure to delight the whole family. Well, almost the whole family, every song but Judith has a lighter tone too it. The aforementioned Judith is the heaviest song on the album and rightfully so, it's a song about learning of betrayal from something that you placed faith in and learning that one can live without it. As far as personally I have listened to the entire CD from start to finish without random and all that other stuff a total of about 600 times. I must say that if you know the words and actually sit and follow the disc from track to track, it feels as though Maynard is describing to you the path one would take on a journey of self-discovery, a journey of discovering ones religion per-say. Although you can apply to any part of your life, it has a certain holding to religion as that seems to be what it is shouting about the most.
All in all, the disc has its strange transitions and short songs built for the radio. Maynards voice is what gives these songs their texture and ultimately their go. So for that I give this album:
3 and a half paws out of 5.
Thirteenth Step - Their second effort was even better than the first. I admit, it's different, it was a little difficult to get into at first but after forcing myself through the CD by driving and only bringing that disc along I got to know all of the tracks. Once again, this disc has a very distinct theme, even the title suggests it. The Thirteenth Step has a very emotional way of expressing what I can only think to be what a person would go through during their discovery and addiction to drugs, alcohol, or any other addictive substance. Once again as with the other disc, the songs are made for radio. There's a more subtle aggression though, it's hidden. Among the melodic guitars, the more aggressive bass, and less abrasive drumming, the aggression is there. The songs I will admit are easier to listen too, but it doesn't have the friendlyness that Mer de Noms did that made it so easy to enjoy. The disc is deffinitely more creative though, with Vanishing and The Nurse Who Loved Me being the more standoutish songs that are the more obscure, meaning less common type of writing. On this disc, unlike the last effort, Maynards voice doesn't carry the music as obviously as it did. The writing is tighter, better, everything compliments everything that is playing. With singles like Weak and Powerless and The Outsider, you can't go wrong with this one. Best pick on this disc: Gravity.
All in all this band will have a lot more pull in the radio world than Tool would, but again, they are two entirely different bands, with Maynard being the ONLY similarity.
4 out of 5 paws
eMotion - This disc, in my opinion is awful. Plain and simple. It's political, it has remixes, and the music is jumbled to the point where it sounds more like noise. Personally there's nothing more I can say. Well, except, I won't ever buy it.
2 out of 5 paws (I gave more than I originally wanted because it's played on the radio and all though I don't like it, I still think you should check it out for yourself.)
The Outsider DVD - This is great, it has the uncensored version of The Outsider music video and the first three episodes of Bikini Bandits. The DVD is only about 10 bucks, hardly worth that much money, but at the sametime you really can't buy a DVD+/-R for much less. It's a good DVD though. It's fun to watch the video because it's uncut and entertaining.
3.5 of 5 paws (would be more if the price was less)
I have not seen APC live yet so I cannot comment on them as a live show, but the band itself being as though their share a singer with Tool, they are really good on disc. If you don't know of them, buy one of their CDs, or copy one, however you get one, get one. You will not be disappointed.
Reviewmutt------------